Rooting In Water vs. Soil: Where Do Roots Grow Faster And Better?

A lot of people are under the impression that plants need to be rooted in the soil, but this isn’t true.

Plants actually root well in water and many of the exotic plants you see at the garden centers and nurseries have been rooting their roots in water or even cement for many years.

Plants also root well in sand and many of the containers that are used for container gardens have been filled with sand and the roots of the plants have been able to take hold.

Plants do not root in sand or cement, they will root where the rootstock was rooted.

It’s a good idea to place the container in water, but this should only be for a few hours or so. Do not let the container sit in water for any longer than this.

If you do, the roots will rot and the plant will not grow properly. When plants root in water, their roots spread out to find the nutrients in the water.

Read Also:- Aloe Vera Light Requirements (Growing Tips at Home) 

If the roots find the nutrients in the water, they will continue to grow until the water is drained. If you don’t drain the water from the container, the plants will not be able to get all of the nutrients they need to grow.

Many gardeners choose to use plant food or compost when they are watering their plants. This is a good idea, but you can be certain that the roots of your favorite plants will continue to grow.

The roots are the supply line for the plant. When you use plant food, you are limiting the amount of nutrients the plant receives.

However, by using compost, the nutrients are available for the plants to use.

One of the biggest factors of the rootstock is the width of the root system. The width of the root system is related to the amount of water the plant can tolerate before it becomes stressed. There are some plants that cannot stand very much moisture, so they need to have a deeper root system.

If the rootstock has a shallow root system, it can get stressed if there is too much water. As it becomes more stressed, the roots will begin to die.

In this instance, the plants lose their ability to take in water and photosynthesis will be greatly affected.

To solve this problem, you need to make sure you use a high quality rootstock and water the plants carefully. It is recommended that you water the plants in a drip irrigation system so the roots are never completely dried out.

When you do this, the roots will have plenty of water available to them.

Read Also:- Should I Cut the Brown Tips Off My Aloe Plant?

By watering the roots in a drip irrigation system, you are guaranteeing that they get enough water to keep growing, healthy and strong.

Many gardeners mistakenly believe that if a plant is in good shape, it will automatically grow into a large plant. While this is possible, most plants are only 2 – 3 inches long.

For larger plants, it is best to simply use a good rootstock which will provide the right amount of support so your plants can grow into large plants.

Roots should never be left on the plant because they can cause damage to the main stem or can rot the rootstock itself. If you decide to use a rootstock for your plants, you should be sure that you water the roots frequently.

Read Also:- Aloe Vera Plant Turning Brown and Soft? (causes and solutions)

Do roots grow faster in water or soil?

root system

When you are considering whether or not you should prune your garden after they have been established, you might be wondering, “do plant roots grow faster in water or soil?”

The answer to this question depends upon what type of root system in your plant has. Plants that have a shallow root system do better in either medium.

But plants with a deeper root system do better in water.

Soils with a finer texture tend to attract a larger number of tiny roots, and these roots grow faster than those in a medium.

On the flip side, roots from a deeper root system generally find the lowest spots in the soil. This is why the well-drained, sandy types are so often used in vegetable gardens and flower beds. But they don’t work very well for most plants, since they cannot rest beneath a layer of loose soil.

For this reason, plant herbs, shrubs and small trees in well-rotted compost, or line the base of your flowerbeds with a layer of bark.

Although many gardeners are beginning to use drip systems, many still wonder, “do plant roots grow faster in water or soil?”

Read Also:- Why Is My Aloe Plant Turning Brown?

Even though the roots are only an inch or two long in water, it takes some time for them to penetrate the soil, and they may not be able to absorb the water completely.

They do, however, tend to stay near the source of water until the water has fully saturated the soil, at which point they die and can be harvested.

In the soil, plants have a root system of several different types of roots. Each has a job to do, but all play an important part.

At the surface, the main root system supplies the plant with food, allowing it to absorb carbon dioxide from the air. The deeper roots supply plant nutrients, water, and minerals.

So, why does the question, “do plant roots grow faster in water or soil?” arise? The answer is found when looking deeper into the roots of a plant. The deeper roots will actually take up most, if not all, of the water that reaches a plant as it grows.

This is why some plants will grow well in floodwater and others will not. One of the reasons for this is because the roots are so deeply penetrated into the ground.

The roots also have a hard time absorbing much of the nutrient value of the water, as the water just gets absorbed by the first few inches.

Thus, a plant that needs lots of water or wants to flourish in a dry climate will do better in a slightly moist environment, where it will simply spread out the roots and take as much water as it needs.

A similar principle may be applied to whether do plant roots grow faster in clay or sand?

Read Also:-  White Fuzzy Mold on Plant Soil? (How to Treat It)

Is it better to propagate in water or soil?

Propagation of a plant is important because the type of plant life you are replicating will determine many aspects of the success of the reproduction.

For example, if you are planting tomatoes in water, you want to use good watering techniques so your plant life has plenty of water to feed the tomato plants. If you are planting a vine to frame a gazebo, you want the vine to reach full height to establish a firm frame.

Therefore, knowing what plant life you are replicating and how you are doing it will make it easier for you to decide what method and time of care to use.

In most cases, the best way to propagate a plant is through root division. If you divide a plant into two or more divisions, you are ensuring that each half of the plant has enough space to grow properly.

Therefore, it is better to divide your plant into segments and replant these segments separately. This allows each plant the chance to develop into fully grown and mature plants.

There are exceptions to this general principle, however. If you have a plant with a long stem and very thick roots, it may be necessary to separate the stem from the rest of the plant and use the roots to help support the entire plant.

This can be a very labor-intensive process, but in some cases it may be the only option.

Some types of vines, such as roses, can also be propagated by detaching a single branch and allowing it to grow along a new stem.

This technique can be used with a variety of plant life. It is sometimes more difficult to grow certain kinds of vines and leaves, for example, so it may be necessary to use other methods.

Read Also:- How Much Space Do Pumpkins Need To Grow?

You may find it necessary to do some research before trying to reproduce an unknown type of vine or plant.

Sometimes the only way to learn about the correct method of how to propagate a plant is to visit a plant nursery to view a gallery of pictures of plants that can be reproduced.

Watering is usually the easiest method of planting a seed. Plants can be successfully started growing after just one watering.

Some experts suggest waiting until the soil has about two inches of water in it when you are considering whether to try to grow a plant from seed.

This is because it takes longer for the roots of a plant that has already grown under the soil to completely absorb the water from the surrounding environment.

Soil is usually the most difficult factor for most people when they consider whether to start growing a plant from seed or whether they should simply place a plant in a pot. Many plants, such as herbs, can grow quite well in potting mix, especially if you do not water them often.

This is because the plant will find it much easier to root itself to the pot rather than have its roots soak up all the water from the surrounding soil.

However, even some plants can do better with being planted directly into the garden. If you plan on planting a vine or a bush into a small area, you may want to see if you can find a friend who grows this type of plant who might be willing to give you some advice on how best to plant it.

Are water roots different than soil roots?

There are many reasons that people might wonder about this question – what exactly are water roots? What can they do to affect your garden in particular and how can they be used?

In this article, we’ll take a quick look at what water roots are, how they interact with the environment and whether they should form a part of your landscape design plan.

After reading this article you should have a good understanding of water roots and what they can do on your property.

Read Also:- What Do You Put Under Grow Bags? (4 Options)

We first need to define the root, so let’s simplify by thinking about plants as having ” roots “down” their stems. Water roots penetrate deeply into the ground and take root where they are expected.

So if you put up a tree and plant a weed at its base, you will get a good result because the roots of the tree will actually penetrate the weed and take hold of it.

If however you plant the grass at the same spot and plant a weed at its top, you won’t get the same results because the grass will be growing up the stem while the weed is on the bottom and just below the surface. The point is that water roots form a strong network of roots that extend from the earth up into the soil.

The specific type of route that you see when you examine a root ball in your garden is known as the “athong” root system. This is actually a branch of the trunk of the plant.

When we refer to “root system”, we are really talking about the network of roots that compose a plant’s root system.

A few examples of vascular plants include a bean, a potato, or a tomato. Soil on the other hand refers to the upper layer of the earth which includes rock, gravel, and other organic material.

Soil, like water, holds nutrients and water and makes sure that the plant doesn’t starve. Plants use all of their water and nutrients from the soil to grow.

Soils with plenty of water or a lot of dissolved oxygen are dark in color and are usually nutrient rich. A soil with little water or poor quality oxygen is clay-based and soils that are acidic are alkaline in nature. So are water roots different than soil roots?

Water roots penetrate deeply down into the earth so they can get to the plants where they need the nutrients that the roots need for growth.

However, soil roots only reach the surface where it is possible for them to attach themselves to a mineral or rock surface.

Water roots also spread out rather quickly due to their ability to use small gaps and holes in the soil.

So the bottom of the tree happens to have more water roots than the top of the tree, therefore it “grows” faster than the roots would on a soil-based tree.

Read Also:- Rex Begonia Light Requirements (Gardener’s Guide)


In this insightful guide on PlantGardener, discover the art of rooting plants in water and soil. Explore the step-by-step process to propagate your favorite plants successfully. From selecting the right cuttings to providing optimal conditions, learn the secrets to nurturing healthy root systems. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned gardener, this article offers valuable tips and techniques to enhance your propagation skills. Uncover the joys of watching your cuttings flourish into thriving plants, adding beauty and greenery to your indoor or outdoor spaces. Elevate your gardening journey with Plant Gardener’s comprehensive rooting guide.


Both water and soil root systems help to keep the entire plant alive. Plant roots help the tree stay healthy by extracting oxygen from the air and storing it in their root system.

The oxygen is carried out of the root system and helps the tree to absorb water, nutrients, and other elements.

Soil on the other hand, just acts as a sponge and absorbs everything it can get through soil. Therefore, the debate over whether or not the roots make up the root system or the water is a pointless discussion.


To Plant a Garden is to Believe in Tomorrow!

Sign up for our newsletter and turn your thumb greener with each season. No spam, just blooms. Subscribe now and start nurturing nature's beauty with us!

You have Successfully Subscribed!